Quote:
Originally Posted by bishoph
While I certainly do not seek to argue about the particulars of "the church" versus "a church," I would have to disagree with you in calling the UPCI a church.
IMHO the UPCI is a ministerial association which was founded for the sake of fellowship and the propagation of the Gospel to the whole world. In a legal sense it is a non-profit corporation, nothing less nothing more. There are individual ministers and churches which are associated and or affiliated with said corporation, the UPCI, however, is not a church as an entity within itself.
|
With respect bishop, "In a legal sense" every 501c(3) org is simply a not-for-profit organization. And this includes virtually every Apostolic "church" in North America. To use this line of reasoning, I take it that you would agree that proselytizing every Apostolic church is now available without any hint of criticism for those who do so? Where is your church, by the way? Maybe I should start contacting your saints with a focused effort at evangelizing them to a "better" way of thinking and having church.
Quote:
Originally Posted by bishoph
I personally think this is one of the problems that UPC "lifers" have at times, they cannot separate the fact that the UPCI corp/organization is not a church. This is because, to some extent, this has been implied if not taught on a national/international level.
|
My take on this is that with the advance of the teachings of exclusivism by the so-called "Water & Spirit" proponents that a climate was created that caused many saints to say things like "the UPC is
THE CHURCH." That was usually followed up by equivocations to include GIBs and and smaller OP orgs. But the general theme usually stood.
It was only among the ministery that clarifications were made about the org being "for the beneifit and fellowship of like minded ministers..." But when it really comes to it, the whole argument is obscured by a lot of quibbling and assertions from every angle over the years.
I think that to say now, that the UPC is "not a church" and thus is somehow excempt from the rules of proselytizing is disengenuous. Most of the same people who say that now are either eager to continue to sow discord or are sympathetic to those who do. Several years ago, these same folks would have been appalled by such behavior.
Just because their opinions have changed doesn't mean that eternal principles based upon the Word of God have changed as well.