Quote:
Originally Posted by bkstokes
Who conceded that God gave these desires? Do you want to talk about circular reasoning? Let us only talk about these beliefs using logical syllogisms. Let us see which arguments are circular.
|
If God created us, and we are born with a sin nature (which is something that we have no control over, we cannot
chose to be born
without a sin nature. And if having a sin nature causes us to commit sin, then how can it be said that we have free will, when we have no choice but by our very nature to committ sin.
Brads point was that God seemingly creates us as flawed, and then turns around and punishes us for those flawed.
Yes, you may argue that God created Adam and Eve without flaw and without sin nature, and they
chose to sin. However, we were not given the same choice.