Apostolic Friends Forum

Apostolic Friends Forum (https://www.apostolicfriendsforum.com/index.php)
-   The D.A.'s Office (https://www.apostolicfriendsforum.com/forumdisplay.php?f=65)
-   -   Apo.Emergent Changers Catering to "WORLDLINGS" ... (https://www.apostolicfriendsforum.com/showthread.php?t=30108)

DAII 05-26-2010 06:08 AM

Apo.Emergent Changers Catering to "WORLDLINGS" ...
 
Found this precious nugget of hooey linked at the Martyn Ballestero blog:

Quote:

Apostolic Times Restored
Posted in Emergent Church, Holiness, Worship on May 25, 2010 by howarddavis

It has been a good number of years since I published The Apostolic Times. For approximately 20 years, every month, 3000 copies of the 10 to 20 page tabloid were mailed out to Preachers across the USA, Canada and to Missionaries on the field. I was careful to hold true to Bible Doctrines. When it came to things of Holiness Standards, and my honest heart-felt beliefs, I made it plain. I wasn’t mean spirited in the things I wrote, nor, did I water-down or side step any issue that I felt needed a voice of challenge and response. Sure, I received responses. Some Pro, and some Con, mostly Pro. I can only hope for the same, as I feel led, to once again venture into publishing words of challenge to some of the false doctrines and unholy practices, which are being promoted among us today.

Now, that the dust has settled, the apology made, forgiveness received, and the hurts healed; let’s get back to the battle of the “Culture Changers.”

There are Changes being promoted among UPCI Churches, by young, and some not so young, Preachers. These CHANGERS want to totally change the form and order of Church Services, and are ACCOMPLISHING it in some Churches. I understand they don’t think doing so will do away with Godly, tried and proven Church services. Services which are a breath of Heaven. Services filled with Holy Dignity and Order. Services in which the very presence of the Lord is felt, and the Glory of God comes down with conviction that brings sinners to repentance and Salvation. These CHANGERS seem to be totally unaware that they are catering to rebellious, hippy mind set, drug infested, immoral, street living Worldlings. These Worldlings have been steeped in, and engrossed in the {deafening-hype-noise} music of the World. They don’t need some misguided people trying to save them, by offering the same STUFF, in any kind of a Church Setting.

For the most part, I find that they are men who have inherited a Church from their Father, or, a good Godly Holiness preaching Pastor, that has given his very life to build the Church. These Men have on the most part, inherited good solid Churches. Churches formed and built on solid Bible centered Teaching, and powerful Preaching. That Pastor gave His life fighting devils, false doctrines, and sometimes false brethren, to build the Church. These Changers have never SWEAT-OUT the building of a Church from the ground up. Therefore, they don’t know the worth and preciousness of a real God fearing Holiness Church. A Church that has been taught [hopefully] SEPARATION from the World.

1st John 2:15, “Love Not the World, neither the things that are in the World. If any man love the World, the love of the Father is not in him.” Also, The Holy Ghost said, 11Cor. 6:17, “come out from among them, and be ye separate, saith the Lord, and touch not the unclean thing.” Again, the Spirit of the Lord wrote, Rev. 18:4, “…come out of HER, my people, that ye be not PARTAKERS of HER SINS, and that ye receive not HER plagues.” God in His love, has instructed us, yes, commanded us to COME OUT of THEM. {Q} Who is the THEM? {A} The WORLD, of course. Then He commanded us to COME OUT of HER. {Q} Who is the Her? {A} The last days FALSE CHURCH. The so-called Emerging-Church is right in the middle of the last days False Church. IT IS NOT AN EMERGING CHURCH, they are SUBMERGING. All that go that way are submerging into worldliness and false doctrines. Step {1}, leave Holiness. Step {2}, leave Sound Doctrine. Oh Yes they will! God Himself will see to it. Read II Thess. 2:11-15.

So, our wonderful and lovely Saviour, Jesus Christ, commands us to SEPARATE ourselves from the WORLD and the FALSE CHURCH. He said, don’t love the World, don’t love the Things in the World. Think with me my dear Brethren, if ROCK and HEAVY METAL music {noise} is not a THING of the WORLD, there is no validity to what Jesus commanded us. Also, He commanded us, don’t touch the UNCLEAN THING. If ROCK and HEAVY METAL type music, in an Apostolic Church is not an UNCLEAN THING, there are no unclean things in this world. I believe some of the men who have set out to “change” worship in Apostolic Churches are sincere, but they are so woefully wrong. They don’t know what horrible damage they are doing to their Church, when they infuse this wicked practice into it. Any Church that becomes engrossed, drowned and buried in this practice will find themselves members of the Laodicean False Church, of these LAST DAYS.

If you have the stomach for it, go to Youtube, bring up Apostolic Church Worship, you will be absolutely shocked at what you see being passed off as worship in an Apostolic Church. A pitch black auditorium, loud screaming and yelling, just like a Rock Concert, presumable by Holy Ghost filled young people. Totally ignorant of what they look and sound like. Super loud drums, keyboards, bass, guitars, growing louder and louder, suddenly there is an explosion of blinding and stabbing lights on the performers, lights rolling and oscillating across the ceiling and stage props, all this accompanied by great leaping flames of fire, 3/5/6 feet high on several areas of the stage, guys out on ramps among the kids, swaying and playing guitars. You ask, where did these children learn this stuff? They have been watching it on TV, the Internet, or worse yet, they have been going to Rock Concerts. In light of this, The Beach Boys, and their ilk, will have to hang their heads in shame. Astounding! Disgustingly putrid, to say the least.

Apostolic????????????, Fat Chance.

Unclean, unclean cries the Leper. This practice is to me Spiritual Leprosy. It is the spirit of error and it is, Unclean.

They, the “Changers” have for the most part, paid nothing nor sacrificed their life to bring a Church into being, so, they blindly introduce a Rock Concert with all of its noise and shameful carrying on, and call it Apostolic. Their word is, The Culture! The Culture! They say, we’ve got to work with the Culture. It is a different day and time, they say. Listen to me Brother, every generation thinks it is a modern generation. When I was discharged from the U.S. Navy, in 1946, that was THE modern generation for me. It was just as modern to me, as 2010 is to you. However, let me tell you, when I went to the UPC Church in Fresno, California, where Brother A.V. Kelley was Pastor, I didn’t say to him, this is New Generation, and we young men, I was 22 yrs old, don’t want to have this old Church music and songs. Nor did I say, “Pastor, the Church will have to change so we can reach this Modern Generation.” First, let me say to this pitiful kind of reasoning, HOGWASH! And, let me tell you what the Pastor would have said. He would say, “you see that door you came through? It swings both ways.”

The church of Jesus Christ didn’t change for me, and it’s not changing for you or anyone else. We, of my generation, didn’t display the gall, audacity, insolence and bare faced ignorance to try to change the Church to fit our generation. No, we came in, out of a mod generation, a changing time all around us, we were happy to find refuge in the Church of the Living God. We never gave it a thought, we dropped the worldly music that we danced to, played pool to, went the movies and parties to, yes we dropped the worlds music like a hot potato and loved the Church music, the standards of Holiness and conduct. We were so thankful just to find Salvation. This generation will do the same, if they are taught right, and not catered to, to their flesh. If they are witnessed to by Holy Ghost filled Young People that are not afraid to say, I’m Pentecostal, here is how we dress, here are the songs we sing in Church, thereby giving Glory to our wonderful Saviour.

There will be, no doubt, lewd ungodliness following this Change in the appeal to the Culture. Instead of Godly Church Music; loud stadium twanging, ear splitting sounds. Tinkling cymbals and sounding brass; shock waves of sounds that insult the intellect. Soul and Spirit polluting gyrations of flesh gratifying hard-acid-rock NOISE. Theatrics, instead of a Holy, sincere, heartfelt worship service. Some Churches that were once greatly blessed, have now, because of these CHANGERS, become barren waste-lands of ungodly sounds and practices. There is not even a ghost of resemblance to their past Holiness. If the Pastor, who gave his life building an Apostolic Church were to see his life’s work now, he would be SHAMED, SHAMED, SHAMED.

We are bombarded daily, by politicians yelling about “Political Correctness.” I’m not concerned with so-called political correctness. I am concerned with “Biblical and Holy Ghost Culture, Correctness.”

According to Isaiah 1:2-4, Holiness is the most essential element of God’s Nature. {J.S.}

The direction being taken by these Fellows, will lead to similar conditions, in the House of God.

Away with all the CULTURAL TRASH.

Let’s get back to Holy and modest Church Services, and the preaching of God’s Word. Let’s please the Lord Jesus, by returning to HIS CULTURE.

Amen

http://howarddavis.wordpress.com

Howard, which of these "emerging" UPCI churches were inherited?:

http://www.sflighthouse.com/
http://www.yourjourney.tv/
http://www.alcplano.org/
www.nstarchurch.com


And Howard .... who in Pentecost, let alone planet earth, uses the word "WOLRDLING"?
Did you sign an affirmation statement not to contend to the disunity of the brethren? Why did you lie?

I know, Marty, I AGREE, we need his voice in Pentecost as a benchmark and fence in avoiding the wastelands of RADICALIST EXTREMISM and BEING OUT OF TOUCH WITH ANY SEMBLANCE OF BALANCE AND REALITY.

DAII 05-26-2010 07:00 AM

Re: Apo.Emergent Changers Catering to "WORLDLINGS"
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by DAII (Post 916497)
Found this precious nugget of hooey linked at the Martyn Ballestero blog:

Howard, which of these "emerging" UPCI churches were inherited?:

http://www.sflighthouse.com/
http://www.yourjourney.tv/
http://www.alcplano.org/
www.nstarchurch.com


And Howard .... who in Pentecost, let alone planet earth, uses the word "WOLRDLING"?
Did you sign an affirmation statement not to contend to the disunity of the brethren? Why did you lie?

I know, Marty, I AGREE, we need his voice in Pentecost as a benchmark and fence in avoiding the wastelands of RADICALIST EXTREMISM and BEING OUT OF TOUCH WITH ANY SEMBLANCE OF BALANCE AND REALITY.

Caveat Apostolic believer: the Holiness police are not content in only policing your wardrobe but now have a checklist to police the liturgy of the apostolic church service and technology used in said service.

Btw, Stephen Gregory, I read your comment to Howard. How can you rejoice in a blog article that viciously attacks his ministerial peers? Is this how you now define "wholesome"?
And why do you care, you're not UPC

Aquila 05-26-2010 07:07 AM

Re: Apo.Emergent Changers Catering to "WORLDLINGS"
 
The UPCI needs to repent.

Mirth1981 05-26-2010 07:19 AM

Re: Apo.Emergent Changers Catering to "WORLDLINGS"
 
Wow...that was so harsh. :irate

rgcraig 05-26-2010 07:50 AM

Re: Apo.Emergent Changers Catering to "WORLDLINGS"
 
What I don't understand is why worry about what someone else is doing. Guess it exposes the inconsistencies.

Baron1710 05-26-2010 08:06 AM

Re: Apo.Emergent Changers Catering to "WORLDLINGS"
 
You know that was so weird that it could almost be satire. It almost has the feel of someone mocking the ultra-con position.

As for the "loud" music, that is nothing new to Pentecost.

Mirth1981 05-26-2010 08:09 AM

Re: Apo.Emergent Changers Catering to "WORLDLINGS"
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Baron1710 (Post 916549)
You know that was so weird that it could almost be satire. It almost has the feel of someone mocking the ultra-con position.

It's strange that these people don't see themselves...and how bizarre they can come across. Or do they?

RandyWayne 05-26-2010 08:11 AM

Re: Apo.Emergent Changers Catering to "WORLDLINGS"
 
The only place the terms Rock, and Acid Rock music seems to be used anymore is in conservative churches. And really.... the Beach Boys, as an example?? This guy never grew beyond the anti-rock seminars of the early to mid 80's.

Mirth1981 05-26-2010 08:16 AM

Re: Apo.Emergent Changers Catering to "WORLDLINGS"
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by RandyWayne (Post 916551)
And really.... the Beach Boys, as an example?? This guy never grew beyond the anti-rock seminars of the early to mid 80's.

Come to think of it, that's pretty funny! :ursofunny

missourimary 05-26-2010 08:33 AM

Re: Apo.Emergent Changers Catering to "WORLDLINGS"
 
I didn't read the whole article, but I do wonder where the author of the article had his head stuck in the sand at for the last decade. Missouri Youth Conventions have used smoke, lighting affects, very rock concert style music and staging, and so forth for years. The last one I went to was about 1998. Headquarters attends, approves, and in many cases at least a few of them help foot the bill. And I believe it was actually a General Conference that I attended in the early '90s where I first saw the sorts of things described here. And the most conservative meetings I've been in (in Kansas) incorporate a massive speaker system: four stacks approximately 15' tall, plus monitors and smaller speakers around the platform. Believe me, your clothes move with the vibrations, even during the preaching but especially during the music. And not just in front of the speakers. Professional sound technicians are paid to come in and operate it. I know some deaf people who can hear in those services. Literally. And that's in the ultra-ultra-ultra conservative movement!

Where has this guy been?

n david 05-26-2010 08:39 AM

Re: Apo.Emergent Changers Catering to "WORLDLINGS"
 
Quote:

I understand they don’t think doing so will do away with Godly, tried and proven Church services. Services which are a breath of Heaven. Services filled with Holy Dignity and Order.
I didn't know there was a certain way services had to be ... I neither got the memo, nor did I see that in the upci rulebook.

Pressing-On 05-26-2010 08:55 AM

Re: Apo.Emergent Changers Catering to "WORLDLINGS"
 
Taking his age into consideration, I'm not going to knock him for venting. Change is scary for older people and it doesn't make them happy to see it come.

Do we remember reading about George Whitefield walking into factories, not saying a word, and grown men crying because the presence of God was so strong? Now we sit at our computers and gossip about everyone having an opinion when we all have one of our own - don't we, Dan? ;)

DAII 05-26-2010 09:01 AM

Re: Apo.Emergent Changers Catering to "WORLDLINGS"
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by n david (Post 916587)
I didn't know there was a certain way services had to be ... I neither got the memo, nor did I see that in the upci rulebook.

The traditionalist/sacramentalist now requires a rigid,l ritualistic orthodoxy to their liturgy.

*AQuietPlace* 05-26-2010 09:03 AM

Re: Apo.Emergent Changers Catering to "WORLDLINGS"
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by RandyWayne (Post 916551)
The only place the terms Rock, and Acid Rock music seems to be used anymore is in conservative churches. And really.... the Beach Boys, as an example?? This guy never grew beyond the anti-rock seminars of the early to mid 80's.

Or hippies. Hippies have been out of vogue for sometime.

People have always fought change, ever since the beginning of time.

DAII 05-26-2010 09:05 AM

Re: Apo.Emergent Changers Catering to "WORLDLINGS"
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by *AQuietPlace* (Post 916605)
Or hippies. Hippies have been out of vogue for sometime.

People have always fought change, ever since the beginning of time.

Drug-infested hippies. Worldlings.

Jesus did not use this type of language or town when referencing the sinner or unbeliever ... much less a brother. He calls them the "least of these" .... "lost sheep".

Caiphas, maybe. Not Jesus.

If a preacher's wife is addicted to prescription pills .... is she "drug-infested".

DAII 05-26-2010 09:09 AM

Re: Apo.Emergent Changers Catering to "WORLDLINGS"
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by *AQuietPlace* (Post 916605)
Or hippies. Hippies have been out of vogue for sometime.

People have always fought change, ever since the beginning of time.

He's a relic still appealing to the arcane, vitriolic writing style of the Apostolic Contender.
He probably thinks long sideburns are of the debbil.

*AQuietPlace* 05-26-2010 09:13 AM

Re: Apo.Emergent Changers Catering to "WORLDLINGS"
 
I know him, and he's a very sweet and godly man. Just very sure that his beliefs are correct. As are most of us. :D

n david 05-26-2010 09:30 AM

Re: Apo.Emergent Changers Catering to "WORLDLINGS"
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by DAII (Post 916604)
The traditionalist/sacramentalist now requires a rigid,l ritualistic orthodoxy to their liturgy.

Funny thing is they make fun and criticize Catholics, Lutherans and others for having ritualistic orthodoxy in their liturgy too. :lol

deacon blues 05-26-2010 09:37 AM

Re: Apo.Emergent Changers Catering to "WORLDLINGS"
 
The RCC didn't have much tolerance for "Culture Changers" like Martin Luther. Tyndale, Wycliffe, and a whole bunch of others balked established tradition and church culture and impacted the world. The problem is when we think we have the "whole truth" and we're unwilling to move forward as time and history progress. Change is inevitable. If its not altering what is clearly a scriptural edict, why worry?

The "when I was 22 in 1945" argument rings hollow. There was not that vast of a difference between the generation prior to his and his own. The landscape changes so fast now that one generation to the next can seem so far removed.

I'm an 80s generation product. If I tried to lead church with Amy Grant, the Allies, and Dallas Holm, the young people would wonder what was wrong with me. The songs we call hymns are in many cases songs written in the 30s, 40s and 50s. True hymns are HUNDREDS of years old. So essentially the songs he was singing when he got saved were contemporary to their times.

I say "sing unto the Lord a new song!" Elders don't need to be catered to, they should be mature enough that they are happy to see new people, young people, young couples and young families coming into the church. I don't necessarily like everything that modern worship produces, but neither have I ever liked Southern Gospel Quartet music, "The Great Speckled Bird", black gospel songs that use the same old "pick me up, turned me around, placed my feet on solid ground" lines.

The truth is most of these passionate reactions are because of taste, nostalgia and biases.

StillStanding 05-26-2010 10:29 AM

Re: Apo.Emergent Changers Catering to "WORLDLINGS"
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by deacon blues (Post 916643)
The RCC didn't have much tolerance for "Culture Changers" like Martin Luther. Tyndale, Wycliffe, and a whole bunch of others balked established tradition and church culture and impacted the world. The problem is when we think we have the "whole truth" and we're unwilling to move forward as time and history progress. Change is inevitable. If its not altering what is clearly a scriptural edict, why worry?

The "when I was 22 in 1945" argument rings hollow. There was not that vast of a difference between the generation prior to his and his own. The landscape changes so fast now that one generation to the next can seem so far removed.

I'm an 80s generation product. If I tried to lead church with Amy Grant, the Allies, and Dallas Holm, the young people would wonder what was wrong with me. The songs we call hymns are in many cases songs written in the 30s, 40s and 50s. True hymns are HUNDREDS of years old. So essentially the songs he was singing when he got saved were contemporary to their times.

I say "sing unto the Lord a new song!" Elders don't need to be catered to, they should be mature enough that they are happy to see new people, young people, young couples and young families coming into the church. I don't necessarily like everything that modern worship produces, but neither have I ever liked Southern Gospel Quartet music, "The Great Speckled Bird", black gospel songs that use the same old "pick me up, turned me around, placed my feet on solid ground" lines.

The truth is most of these passionate reactions are because of taste, nostalgia and biases.

Great post! I've come to the realization that the "cool" Christian music that was popular when I was young and at college is now "old school!"

It's still my favorite kind of music, and I can cry crocodile tears remembering the great moves of the spirit while singing those songs. My kids just don't get my type of music at all!

Should we force feed the new generations to use Lanny Wolfe style music? I think not!

DAII 05-26-2010 10:32 AM

Re: Apo.Emergent Changers Catering to "WORLDLINGS"
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by n david (Post 916634)
Funny thing is they make fun and criticize Catholics, Lutherans and others for having ritualistic orthodoxy in their liturgy too. :lol

Steeped in tradition as much as the next guy ....
:bigbaby

RandyWayne 05-26-2010 10:53 AM

Re: Apo.Emergent Changers Catering to "WORLDLINGS"
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by deacon blues (Post 916643)
......
I say "sing unto the Lord a new song!" Elders don't need to be catered to, they should be mature enough that they are happy to see new people, young people, young couples and young families coming into the church. I don't necessarily like everything that modern worship produces, but neither have I ever liked Southern Gospel Quartet music, "The Great Speckled Bird", black gospel songs that use the same old "pick me up, turned me around, placed my feet on solid ground" lines.

The truth is most of these passionate reactions are because of taste, nostalgia and biases.

"put me up and take my heart and make me happy..... Ya ya ya coco jamboo ya ya hey...."

I agree with you about your personal music tastes. It could have been the fact that the only acceptable music while we were in the church was hymns and Southern gospel that turned me off so much to it.

RandyWayne 05-26-2010 10:55 AM

Re: Apo.Emergent Changers Catering to "WORLDLINGS"
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by DAII (Post 916610)
He's a relic still appealing to the arcane, vitriolic writing style of the Apostolic Contender.
He probably thinks long sideburns are of the debbil.

I remember that mag well. A half a dozen or so hard lined UC's who were so loud that the average person thought there must have been thousands of them!

DAII 05-26-2010 10:59 AM

Re: Apo.Emergent Changers Catering to "WORLDLINGS"
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by RandyWayne (Post 916735)
I remember that mag well. A half a dozen or so hard lined UC's who were so loud that the average person thought there must have been thousands of them!

The Apostolic Contention was divisive and a "middle finger" to the affirmation and unity statement.

RandyWayne 05-26-2010 11:04 AM

Re: Apo.Emergent Changers Catering to "WORLDLINGS"
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by DAII (Post 916739)
The Apostolic Contention was divisive and a "middle finger" to the affirmation and unity statement.

I know it was published out of Portland, OR and have to wonder how many of those pastors are now either dead or left the UPC to start a wife swapping cult.

MissBrattified 05-26-2010 11:13 AM

Re: Apo.Emergent Changers Catering to "WORLDLINGS"
 
You know, I'm not going to take the time to critique this article, because I'm not terribly offended by it.

Just a thought: Sarah did a persuasive essay a couple of weeks ago, and she chose to write about hip-hop lyrics, and how they possibly encourage aggressive, immoral & criminal behavior, in addition to being degrading to women and encouraging disrespect toward women.

I did not shape her outcome beforehand, and allowed her to do deep research, including reading lyrics and watching videos that would normally be off limits. It was carefully supervised for her protection, but she was exposed to some content that she found shocking. We ended up diverging into heavy metal and "horror-core", in addition to hip-hop and rap.

ANYway, in the midst of the research, we came across a study where a researcher had placed 30 boys in three rooms, 10 in each room. (Secular researcher, secular college) She had foosball tables set up in each room. In the first room, the boys played with no music. In the second, there was music playing, but no lyrics. And in the third, there was the same music playing, but with the lyrics. (If I recall correctly, it was heavy metal) Their observations were that in the first room, the behavior was normal, but in the 2nd and 3rd, it was more aggressive and loud. Since the behavior in rooms 2 and 3 were similar, she concluded that it was the music itself that prompted the change in behavior, and not necessarily the lyrics.

We read a report in one of our science magazines about different sounds being used to calm monkeys, and also to get them to behave aggressively or anxiously. The inference was that humans would be affected similarly. We watched a show on the History channel awhile back that showed how drum rhythms were used to bring people into a sort of emotional frenzy during ancient tribal rituals and celebrations.

And, of course, as an Apostolic musician, I KNOW that music can and has been used to manipulate the emotional tone in a church service.

I said all that to say: There is some merit to the idea that certain types of sounds, including in the form of "music" has a direct effect on human behavior. So while older ministers may articulate that point differently, they weren't entirely wrong.

deacon blues 05-26-2010 11:13 AM

Re: Apo.Emergent Changers Catering to "WORLDLINGS"
 
We used to call it the Apostolic Offender

Aquila 05-26-2010 11:46 AM

Re: Apo.Emergent Changers Catering to "WORLDLINGS"
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by MissBrattified (Post 916761)
You know, I'm not going to take the time to critique this article, because I'm not terribly offended by it.

Just a thought: Sarah did a persuasive essay a couple of weeks ago, and she chose to write about hip-hop lyrics, and how they possibly encourage aggressive, immoral & criminal behavior, in addition to being degrading to women and encouraging disrespect toward women.

I did not shape her outcome beforehand, and allowed her to do deep research, including reading lyrics and watching videos that would normally be off limits. It was carefully supervised for her protection, but she was exposed to some content that she found shocking. We ended up diverging into heavy metal and "horror-core", in addition to hip-hop and rap.

ANYway, in the midst of the research, we came across a study where a researcher had placed 30 boys in three rooms, 10 in each room. (Secular researcher, secular college) She had foosball tables set up in each room. In the first room, the boys played with no music. In the second, there was music playing, but no lyrics. And in the third, there was the same music playing, but with the lyrics. (If I recall correctly, it was heavy metal) Their observations were that in the first room, the behavior was normal, but in the 2nd and 3rd, it was more aggressive and loud. Since the behavior in rooms 2 and 3 were similar, she concluded that it was the music itself that prompted the change in behavior, and not necessarily the lyrics.

We read a report in one of our science magazines about different sounds being used to calm monkeys, and also to get them to behave aggressively or anxiously. The inference was that humans would be affected similarly. We watched a show on the History channel awhile back that showed how drum rhythms were used to bring people into a sort of emotional frenzy during ancient tribal rituals and celebrations.

And, of course, as an Apostolic musician, I KNOW that music can and has been used to manipulate the emotional tone in a church service.

I said all that to say: There is some merit to the idea that certain types of sounds, including in the form of "music" has a direct effect on human behavior. So while older ministers may articulate that point differently, they weren't entirely wrong.

Here's a great book that addresses a lot of what you're talking about...

http://www.amazon.com/This-Your-Brai.../dp/0525949690

pelathais 05-26-2010 11:51 AM

Re: Apo.Emergent Changers Catering to "WORLDLINGS"
 
Having attended Pentecostal services all of my life I was unaware that there was ever any "form and order to the services."

pelathais 05-26-2010 11:53 AM

Re: Apo.Emergent Changers Catering to "WORLDLINGS"
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by *AQuietPlace* (Post 916605)
Or hippies. Hippies have been out of vogue for sometime.

People have always fought change, ever since the beginning of time.

That in fact is "the mark of the beast" - or the mark of the created thing in its rebellion against the Creator.

Both John and Daniel made this very clear.

DAII 05-26-2010 11:55 AM

Re: Apo.Emergent Changers Catering to "WORLDLINGS"
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by pelathais (Post 916800)
Having attended Pentecostal services all of my life I was unaware that there was ever any "form and order to the services."

Organized chaos?

deacon blues 05-26-2010 12:11 PM

Re: Apo.Emergent Changers Catering to "WORLDLINGS"
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by MissBrattified (Post 916761)
You know, I'm not going to take the time to critique this article, because I'm not terribly offended by it.

Just a thought: Sarah did a persuasive essay a couple of weeks ago, and she chose to write about hip-hop lyrics, and how they possibly encourage aggressive, immoral & criminal behavior, in addition to being degrading to women and encouraging disrespect toward women.

I did not shape her outcome beforehand, and allowed her to do deep research, including reading lyrics and watching videos that would normally be off limits. It was carefully supervised for her protection, but she was exposed to some content that she found shocking. We ended up diverging into heavy metal and "horror-core", in addition to hip-hop and rap.

ANYway, in the midst of the research, we came across a study where a researcher had placed 30 boys in three rooms, 10 in each room. (Secular researcher, secular college) She had foosball tables set up in each room. In the first room, the boys played with no music. In the second, there was music playing, but no lyrics. And in the third, there was the same music playing, but with the lyrics. (If I recall correctly, it was heavy metal) Their observations were that in the first room, the behavior was normal, but in the 2nd and 3rd, it was more aggressive and loud. Since the behavior in rooms 2 and 3 were similar, she concluded that it was the music itself that prompted the change in behavior, and not necessarily the lyrics.

We also read a report in one of our science magazines about different sounds being used to calm monkeys, and also get them to behave aggressively or anxiously. The inference was that humans would be affected similarly. We watched a show on the History channel awhile back that showed how drum rhythms were used to bring people into a sort of emotional frenzy during ancient tribal rituals and celebrations.

And, of course, as an Apostolic musician, I KNOW that music can and has been used to manipulate the emotional tone in a church service.

I said all that to say: There is some merit to the idea that certain types of sounds, including in the form of "music" has a direct effect on human behavior. So while older ministers may articulate that point differently, they weren't entirely wrong.

Correct. I dont believe anything goes. I just feel the article mentioned is full of holes in its reasoning.

Jermyn Davidson 05-26-2010 04:41 PM

Re: Apo.Emergent Changers Catering to "WORLDLINGS"
 
I think the elderly Preacher has a really good point.


Seriously.



In our efforts to appeal to our generation, we have to appeal to them in a way that allows "room" for the Holy Spirit to move.

I don't think there is anything wrong with holy music that encourages worship and praise.


Would we want to lose the atmosphere that encourages dancing in the Spirit, running the aisles, leaping up and down to the Glory of God?


Some make fun of that stuff and say that it is not real in the first place. For some, maybe it is not. For others it is very real.


I for one, love Hillsongs, Newsboys, and Toby Mac. However, Hillsongs produces music that is 1,000 times more "worship" oriented than Toby Mac.


I wish my church would utilize more of a Shirley Caesar style in some of our music because her music encourages praise. I realize that this will not happen, ever.

But I sure would not want to go to the point of strobe lights and blazing guitars for our services. I wouldn't want to go anywhere near that for our services.

Is that preferrence? Maybe, but I think there is much more to it than that.

*AQuietPlace* 05-26-2010 05:04 PM

Re: Apo.Emergent Changers Catering to "WORLDLINGS"
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Jermyn Davidson (Post 917113)
But I sure would not want to go to the point of strobe lights and blazing guitars for our services.


But, really, is this a wide-spread practice?

Apocrypha 05-26-2010 06:06 PM

Re: Apo.Emergent Changers Catering to "WORLDLINGS"
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by *AQuietPlace* (Post 917126)
But, really, is this a wide-spread practice?

Most churches can barely keep up the skilled manpower to have a decent soundroom. Fewer can support a complex lighting and video operation. I can count the number of churches that seriously invest in a killer lighting system on one hand... and half of those are evangelical or baptist.

RandyWayne 05-26-2010 07:26 PM

Re: Apo.Emergent Changers Catering to "WORLDLINGS"
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Apocrypha (Post 917150)
Most churches can barely keep up the skilled manpower to have a decent soundroom. Fewer can support a complex lighting and video operation. I can count the number of churches that seriously invest in a killer lighting system on one hand... and half of those are evangelical or baptist.

Just imagine your church entrance having one of these screens on the ceiling!
http://www.rachelleb.com/images/2007...nce_aliens.jpg

This in the parking lot. (You gotta wow the visitors!)
http://bucketfountain.com/wp-content...dyed-water.jpg

And a little of this during the sermon.
http://www.broadwayworld.com/columnp...pperfield1.jpg

Praxeas 05-26-2010 07:38 PM

Re: Apo.Emergent Changers Catering to "WORLDLINGS"
 
I remember LS preaching once and mentioned going to another pastors church to preach. When he got there outside the church was piled up all these railings and stuff. He asked the pastor what all this was and he replied it was his alter. He said he was getting rid of it so they can have revival....what a progressive thinker he was and LS approved.

Praxeas 05-26-2010 07:41 PM

Re: Apo.Emergent Changers Catering to "WORLDLINGS"
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Apocrypha (Post 917150)
Most churches can barely keep up the skilled manpower to have a decent soundroom. Fewer can support a complex lighting and video operation. I can count the number of churches that seriously invest in a killer lighting system on one hand... and half of those are evangelical or baptist.

I want to get a serious lighting system and also video cams. But the lighting mostly for two reasons, one for when we have specials like skits and two so we can have directional lighting and our projector screen will not be washed out with light from the fluorescents

But sadly lighting is too much and we have a decent sound system but we need to get new speakers and we have no money for that either

Ev. Duane Williams 05-27-2010 12:45 AM

Re: Apo.Emergent Changers Catering to "WORLDLINGS"
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by RandyWayne (Post 917197)
Just imagine your church entrance having one of these screens on the ceiling!
http://www.rachelleb.com/images/2007...nce_aliens.jpg

This in the parking lot. (You gotta wow the visitors!)
http://bucketfountain.com/wp-content...dyed-water.jpg

And a little of this during the sermon.
http://www.broadwayworld.com/columnp...pperfield1.jpg

I'm there!

I'm one of those "heavy metal NOISE" makers, but most of the older people at our Church like my shredding.

pelathais 05-27-2010 01:26 AM

Re: Apo.Emergent Changers Catering to "WORLDLINGS"
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Praxeas (Post 917202)
I remember LS preaching once and mentioned going to another pastors church to preach. When he got there outside the church was piled up all these railings and stuff. He asked the pastor what all this was and he replied it was his alter. He said he was getting rid of it so they can have revival....what a progressive thinker he was and LS approved.

That kind of altar with railings creates a separation between the platform and the pews. It's a very real physical barrier. Opening it up and making the entire front of the church "the altar" probably had some beneficial effects on his desired revival.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 02:34 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.5
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.